SIGN UP LOGIN
Put Jay Mattlin to work for you
Your local Real Estate Expert
Homes Search
Welcome Photo

Why Choose Jay Mattlin

Your local Real Estate Expert

You loathe typical real estate agent bios. Don’t worry, I do too. They’re like cardboard — stiff, bland, and identical to every other bio out there. Instead of boasting ad nauseum about awards and accomplishments you’re not interested in, I’m taking the novel approach of actually giving you what you want — real answers to questions you’re probably wondering right now.

Will you return my calls and emails?

Yes. Without question.
I realize this is one of the major frustrations the general public has with dealing with agents. I get dozens of calls and emails daily, and I work hard to reply as quickly as possible. My goal is typically within one business day.

I’ve met many Realtors who are jerks. Are you?

Depends on who you ask. If you ask certain agents who have stood between my clients and
their real estate goals, they’ll probably say “yes”. A handful of people think I leave golden
footprints in the sand. Those are the two extremes, and most people’s opinion falls somewhere
in the middle. Here’s what I can tell you: I’m honest and candid. I take pride in being approachable and
friendly. And if you need a quick real estate brain, or a strong dose of honesty, you’re in the right
place. Loyalty to family, clients, and friends is one of my core values. Want to really find out if
I’m a jerk? Mess with one of those people.

Do you have experience doing exactly what I need?

Until you tell me what you need, there is no way of knowing.
These are “strong suits” of mine:

  • Working with new buyers
  • First time sellers
  • USDA / FHA
  • Investment and Rental properties
  • Property Management / Tenant Menagement

If your goal or situation isn’t represented on that list, don’t worry. Contact me anyway. If I can’t help, I can get you referred to an another agent who can.

What kind of work are you really good at?

On a personal level, I’m pretty good at making wine. My pomegranate Zinfandel is amazing I’m told. I’m also pretty good at kayaking, hiking, and in general being outdoors. I’m also really good at giving back to my community because community and culture is important to me and our long term well being as a race.

On a professional level, here are the skill-sets that I’ve developed over the years:

  • Listening. Unfortunately, it’s a lost art these days.
  • Detail oriented. I know everyone says this but I’m pretty obsessive and a bit of a perfectionist.
  • Organized. This is so important in real estate. Even a little disorganization can ruin a deal.
Contact Me

Testimonials

I had never sold a home before and had very little knowledge about the process in selling a home. Jay's knowledge, extensive experience and dedication quickly put my mind at ease. He supported me throughout the process with a personal touch. The communication he provided was prompt and always consistent. I was going through a difficult time with the passing of my mother and the needing to get her home ready to list. Jay was very understanding and compassionate and supportive throughout the process. His integrity and ethics went beyond my expectations and his help during the closing was greatly appreciated. I want to thank Jay once again for everything and congratulations on being elected Vice President of the Lancaster Realtor Board for 2026. Rob DeVol, Lancaster, OH , Seller
As usual, Jay worked his magic on the sale of our home. This is the third transaction Jay has worked on with us. He handled the open house and additional showings while we were on vacation and we sold for much higher than I expected. He shielded us from some time wasting mistakes made by the buyers agent and hand delivered our closing proceeds after the title company noted the buyers forgot to sign some documents. Kait and Fred Murray, Pickerington, OH , Seller
Jay is TOP NOTCH! Jay is the only realtor I will use. He is knowledgeable, helpful, and efficient. Jay makes the selling process as easy as possible and is always there for his clients. Verified by RateMyAgent Angela Seimer , Seller
View All

How Much is Your Home Worth?

Instant Property Valuation Expert Advice Sell For More
Let's Connect

Working with me means more than finding an agent. You gain a professional dedicated to understanding your needs and guiding you through the real estate process with confidence. Your journey starts with a simple conversation.

Let's Connect
Contact Agent Photo

Login to My Homefinder